Former Yorkshire chairman Roger Hutton has criticized the England and Wales Cricket Council’s dealing with of a “deeply disappointing” racism scandal.
However Hutton stated the method was “unhealthy” and referred to as into query its independence.
The previous president stated he was shocked that the ECB’s personal habits through the affair had not been investigated.
The ECB declined to remark.
Final week, the governing physique introduced that it had accomplished a so-called thorough and sophisticated investigation.
Particulars of Yorkshire’s racial abuse first got here to mild in September 2020, when former participant Azeem Rafiq stated the discrimination induced him to commit suicide.
Yorkshire launched a “formal investigation” in response, and a yr later an impartial fee confirmed seven of Rafiq’s 43 expenses.
Nevertheless, the panel’s report was not revealed and no disciplinary motion was taken in opposition to any participant, worker or supervisor as a consequence of its findings.
The consequence provoked widespread criticism, and in November 2021 the ECB suspended worldwide video games at Headingley in Yorkshire, “till it has clearly demonstrated that it will possibly meet the anticipated requirements”. Then – the chairman Hutton resigned, as did CEO Mark Arthur.
Following governance reforms and workers restructuring, the ECB restored Yorkshire’s proper to carry check matches in England. It then accomplished a “thorough and sophisticated” investigation to find out the premise of the allegations in opposition to each the county and the events concerned.
However Hutton – who was crucial of the ECB in testifying earlier than the committee final yr, saying they might have performed extra to assist the county examine Rafiq’s allegations – says it was “deeply disappointing” that the governing physique “ignored”. it’s acceptable to look at the habits of ECB workers.
“You keep in mind the ECB knew about Azem’s accusations earlier than me. They did nothing with them,” he stated.
“They didn’t present help to the YCCC [Yorkshire] regardless of the apparent difficulties he confronted, and when the YCCC requested them for assist, they refused to take action. I consider this ought to be referred to as into query.
“I additionally consider that the ECB’s personal investigation has been poor.”
Hutton criticized the “lack of independence.”
“I’ve raised these considerations with the ECB and so they have rejected them,” he stated.
“I firmly consider that cricket can be higher served by a very impartial regulatory physique, in order that it not solely ensures a good and goal course of that everybody can belief.”
The ECB performed its personal inquiry into the saga, however this was overseen by a regulatory committee with an impartial chair and a number of other impartial members.
The allegations can be heard by an impartial fee of the Cricket Disciplinary Committee.
The ECB has refused to call the accused.
The defendants allegedly embrace former England captain Michael Vaughan and former Yorkshire gamers Matthew Hoggard, Tim Bresnan and Andrew Gale.
BBC Sport has contacted people for feedback.
Former Yorkshire and England captain Vaughan revealed that he had been accused of constructing racist feedback Rafiq and different gamers, however has repeatedly denied the allegations.
Vaughan informed the BBC he by no means made racist feedback whereas within the county. He apologized for some tweets he had despatched earlier.
The ECB has additionally been criticized by three earlier Yorkshire presidents – Colin Graves, Steve Denison and Robin Smith – who, together with Hutton, additionally informed the Telegraph about their considerations concerning the course of.